Jurisprudence 2006

Syllabus

The Textbook

Day 1--August 22

Babylonian Laws I

Babylonian Laws II

Hammurabi--review

Aug. 29--Bib/Plato

Euthyphro and Crito

Paper Guidelines

Nicomachean Eth. I

Nico. Ethics II

Nico. Ethics III

Nico. Ethics IV

Cicero

Justinian's Institutes

Institutes II

Babylonian Talmud

Talmud II

Talmud III

Hugo Grotius

Grotius II

Early Rousseau

Early Rousseau II

Early Rous III

Rousseau's Walks I

Rousseau's Walks II

Rousseau's Walks III

Lisbon Earthquake I

Earthquake II

Bentham's Spirit

Bentham's Words

Benth's "Conversion"

JS Mill I

Mill and Emotions II

Mill and Emotions III

C.C. Langdell

Burying Langdell

Legal Realism I

Legal Realism II

Legal Process

Brown v. Board


Justinian II

Prof. Bill Long 9/10/06

The Opening Sections of the Institutes

One of the most interesting pastimes I know is to learn opening lines of classic texts. It not only gives you a sense of what the work is about, but lets you enter immediately into the mental world of these works. To that end, let's explore the opening sections of the Institutes.

Book I

"TITLE I
OF JUSTICE AND LAW

Justice is the set and constant purpose which gives to every man his due.

1 Jurisprudence is the knowledge of things divine and human, the science of the just and the unjust.

2 Having laid down these general definitions, and our object being the exposition of the law of the Roman people, we think that the most advantageous plan will be to commence with an easy and simple path, and then to proceed to details with a most careful and scrupulous exactness of interpretation. Otherwise, if we begin by burdening the student’s memory, as yet weak and untrained, with a multitude and variety of matters, one of two things will happen: either we shall cause him wholly to desert the study of law, or else we shall bring him at last, after great labour, and often, too, distrustful of his own powers (the commonest cause, among the young, of ill-success), to a point which he might have reached earlier, without such labour and confident in himself, had he been led along a smoother path.

3 The precepts of the law are these: to live honestly, to injure no one, and to give every man his due. 4 The study of law consists of two branches, law public, and law private. The former relates to the welfare of the Roman State; the latter to the advantage of the individual citizen. Of private law then we may say that it is of threefold origin, being collected from the precepts of nature, from those of the law of nations, or from those of the civil law of Rome.

TITLE II
OF THE LAW OF NATURE, THE LAW OF NATIONS,
AND THE CIVIL LAW

The law of nature is that which she has taught all animals; a law not peculiar to the human race, but shared by all living creatures, whether denizens of the air, the dry land, or the sea. Hence comes the union of male and female, which we call marriage; hence the procreation and rearing of children, for this is a law by the knowledge of which we see even the lower animals are distinguished.

1 The civil law of Rome, and the law of all nations, differ from each other thus. The laws of every people governed by statutes and customs are partly peculiar to itself, partly common to all mankind. Those rules which a state enacts for its own members are peculiar to itself, and are called civil law: those rules prescribed by natural reason for all men are observed by all peoples alike, and are called the law of nations. Thus the laws of the Roman people are partly peculiar to itself, partly common to all nations; a distinction of which we shall take notice as occasion offers. 2 Civil law takes its name from the state wherein it binds; for instance, the civil law of Athens, it being quite correct to speak thus of the enactments of Solon or Draco. So too we call the law of the Roman people the civil law of the Romans, or the law of the Quirites; the law, that is to say, which they observe, the Romans being called Quirites after Quirinus. Whenever we speak, however, of civil law, without any qualification, we mean our own; exactly as, when ‘the poet’ is spoken of, without addition or qualification, the Greeks understand the great Homer, and we understand Vergil. But the law of nations is common to the whole human race; for nations have settled certain things for themselves as occasion and the necessities of human life required. For instance, wars arose, and then followed captivity and slavery, which are contrary to the law of nature; for by the law of nature all men from the beginning were born free. The law of nations again is the source of almost all contracts; for instance, sale, hire, partnership, deposit, loan for consumption, and very many others.

3 Our law is partly written, partly unwritten, as among the Greeks. The written law consists of statutes, plebiscites, senatusconsults, enactments of the Emperors, edicts of the magistrates, and answers of those learned in the law. 4 A statute is an enactment of the Roman people, which it used to make on the motion of a senatorial magistrate, as for instance a consul. A plebiscite is an enactment of the commonalty, such as was made on the motion of one of their own magistrates, as a tribune.

...

"11 But the laws of nature, which are observed by all nations alike, are established, as it were, by divine providence, and remain ever fixed and immutable: but the municipal laws of each individual state are subject to frequent change, either by the tacit consent of the people, or by the subsequent enactment of another statute.

12 The whole of the law which we observe relates either to persons, or to things, or to actions. And first let us speak of persons: for it is useless to know the law without knowing the persons for whose sake it was established.

TITLE III
OF THE LAW OF PERSONS

In the law of persons, then, the first division is into free men and slaves."

The only question I want to put to you after this is: Which line or lines stand out to you from the first sections of the Institutes?

2074



Copyright © 2004-2007 William R. Long